After reading the final book in the Dark Legacy of Shannara trilogy, this series has to rank among the better ones I have read from Terry Brooks. It’s a similar story that he’s told before involving descendants of characters he has written in the past in similar situations with similar stakes and similar talismans. Even though he’s not breaking any new ground, and I wouldn’t give this series or this novel high points for originality, it was well written, entertaining, and compelling. It was also a good bit darker than most of Brooks’s other works. Many characters died in the series, and a heavy price was paid even by the survivors.
As far as this novel goes, the weakest part of the book involved Railing Ohmsford seeking out Grianne Ohmsford in an attempt to rescue his brother. That seemed like the least consequential part of the novel that was designed to give Railing something to do. The better parts of the novel involved the Straken Lord and his army of dark creatures escaping the Forebidding and trying to conquer the Four Lands. The battle scenes were well done. Also, the Ellesindil sisters trying to save the Ellcrys was also well done. The build was strong as was the finale. There is everything that you would want in a Shannara book and series represented here so if you like Terry Brooks, you will enjoy reading this.
I thoroughly enjoyed the first two novels and eagerly anticipated finishing the series, which was probably why I was so disappointed with Only Human. This novel fell flat and instead of ending the trilogy with a bang, it ended it with a whimper. It’s hard to say exactly where the novel went wrong, but so much about it annoyed me. I didn’t care for how the main characters reacted to both their time on the foreign planet and then their return. I wasn’t buying how the people of Earth reacted to the aftermath of the alien robots arriving on the planet and killing so many, with the establishment of concentration camps for those who had a higher concentration of alien DNA. It just didn’t make any sense to me. And whereas I enjoyed the style of storytelling, through journal entries and interviews, in this novel it got ridiculous at times. There would be situations where the characters are being chased and shot at but were still dictating a running commentary of the situation. It felt artificial and trite. Oh, and the use of alien words that I didn’t understand was utterly pointless.
That’s not to say that the entire novel was bad. There was some level of intrigue to it, but mostly it didn’t work. In particular the robot fight at the end was just dumb. If you read and enjoyed the first two novels, you would be better off not reading this and coming up with your own ending.
Although I don’t love the fact that every major movie release these days seems to be a part of some existing franchise, and I don’t necessarily think these new Avatar movies need to be made, that didn’t stop me from going to the theater to watch this movie. And I was not disappointed. There were some things that I didn’t like about the movie, but for the most part it was an enjoyable experience.
For me the highlights of the movie were the visuals. The effects, the CGI, the meticulous way that the world of the Naavi were built, were all top notch. This is the sort of movie that you will want to watch on the big screen. I didn’t see the 3D version, so I’m not sure if that would have enhanced the experience or not. The plot and characters were also better than the original movie. It’s been a while since I last saw it, so that is not as fresh in my mind, but this was a more compelling story.
On the downside, not having seen the original in a while, the beginning of the movie was quite confusing and I thought they could have done a better job of bringing the viewer up to speed in the world of Avatar. I also thought the movie was too long. Three plus hours is just too much for a movie. Specifically, the part I felt that could have been cut down was the part when Jake and his family arrive at the water tribes and integrate themselves into the tribes. They could have slashed a half hour from that part without missing too much.
The good in this movie outweighed the bad and I think this will be an enjoyable experience if you choose to venture into a theater to watch it.
It’s hard to give a full review for the first season of House of the Dragon. There was so much going on in the season, and it was quite different than any show I’ve ever seen. Some of it was good and some not so good.
The most jarring aspect of the show were the two time-jumps. At first, I didn’t like the switching of the actors and didn’t think it was entirely necessary to do so, especially since I liked some of the younger actors better, particularly young Rhaenyra. Of course, I didn’t realize that there would be a second time jump, necessitating the changing of the actors. However, it made no sense that they kept Ser Criston Cole and Daemon Targaryen, when the actors playing those roles were so much younger than the characters in the latter part of the season. They didn’t even bother trying to age them.
Game of Thrones was one of my all time favorite shows, and I don’t think season one of House of the Dragon quite measures up to it even though there was a lot about the show that I liked. Whereas Game of Thrones was a mix of magic, palace intrigue, and epic fighting scenes mixed in, House of the Dragon is much more about the palace intrigue, with dragons being more of a side show than the main event. The blend of those elements is what made Game of Thrones work so well.
What stood out on the show was the quality of the acting, especially Paddy Considine as King Viserys I Targaryen and Matt Smith as Daemon Targaryen. The birth scenes were kind of like a war unto themselves and were overdone. The CGI with the dragons improved quite a bit over the years. Some of the gaps in logic were a bit much. As an example, it was so obvious that Rhaenyra’s first children were not from her husband, that it was almost preposterous that they would even try to masquerade it. Also, at the end Rhaenys Targaryen could have wiped out all of her Targaryen enemies and it was silly for her not to.
So, it was a bit of a mixed bag, but the good definitely overshadowed the not so good. It’s a worthy successor to Game of Thrones and I think with less jarring time jumps, the second season should be better than the first.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series. With the bar set high, Waking Gods, did not disappoint. The book takes place a number of years after the end of the first book. It starts with the robot giant, Themis, touring around the world, and preparing just in case aliens invade the planet—and they do. This book features robots coming to Earth, and Themis engaging them in fights. It’s readily apparent that Themis can’t possibly fight all of them. As people die by the millions from these robot encounters, the humans need to find an alternate way of dealing with the situation—a way to prove to the aliens that humans are worthy of surviving as a species.
The quality of the writing in this novel is strong. Although most of the time I didn’t mind the nontraditional storytelling method of using mission logs, journal entries, and interviews to tell the story, sometimes it gets a bit wonky. Like when there is a life and death situation, and the person is narrating real time what is happening. That makes absolutely no sense, and it is clearly a vehicle used to tell the story. In a real life situation, that would never happen. But the story telling is good enough to overcome that. Overall, it was a fun read, with some good twists and reveals along the way. The author is also not afraid to kill off big characters, which can be very risky for the author, but it also often pays big dividends. This is a good novel that I would recommend.
